The Substack "Moment" Accelerates

Rushdie also laid out his vision for the type of writings that would come to populate his profile which he has named quotSalman39s Sea of Storiesquot including that he plans to post twice each week offer both paid and unpaid content and release his latest work of fiction in serialized form through the platform And in an interview with The Guardian also released on September 1st Rushdie told Shelley Hepworth that his foray into Substack would also allow him to fulfill his longstanding desire to write film criticism after having been previously denied the opportunity at The New Yorker when the film critic Rushdie was set to replace decided against taking paternity leaveHow Rushdie describes what he plans to do with his Substack speaks to the eclectic nature of the content the platform supports Rushdie as was alluded to above plans to offer a mix of literary criticism the aforementioned film reviews and quotthe stories behind the stories I39ll be tellingquot while also interacting with readers and fans by answering their questions And as he implies when he speaks of that lack of quotintermediaries or gatekeepersquot we might expect Rushdie39s latest writings to bear some of the trademarks of Substack posts being slightly less toned down or wordsmithed as those final drafts that have undergone multiple rounds of edits and feature input from various editors This is to take a step away from what Bari Weiss another recent arrival to Substack said of the editorial process at today39s New York Times where quotevery line is carefully massaged negotiated and caveatedquotAlthough I am in theory a defender of the traditional editorial process and the benefits that tend to accrue from editors providing insight and feedback the reality Weiss alludes to in the letter from which that above quotation is drawn and a reality also described by others displaced from the traditional outlets who have now taken up a post at Substack is that too much of today39s editorial process is about injecting ideology and certain pieties at the expense of preserving the writer39s own style and perspectivesAs such it is no surprise that many writers and thinkers who do not fit neatly into the current iteration of the twoparty system and its corresponding media analogs would look for alternatives with Substack now being a prime destination From Glenn Loury to Glenn Greenwald to Matt Taibbi wellknown writers many of whom used to be at the legacy brands have gone off on their own via Substack Taibbi39s August 13th piece quotThe Vanishing Legacy of Barack Obamaquot is a prime example of a recent Substack essay to generate considerable attention and discussionAs has been discussed by other commentators many journalists and editors still housed at traditional outlets have been sharply and unreasonably critical of Substack quotthe lady doth protest too muchquot which is likely explained by the threat that Substack may pose to their ways of doing things and of course their business models At times derisively dubbed quotthe Substackeratiquot those writers who successfully make their way on Substack demonstrate two things The first is that they do not in fact need editors And secondly they can accurately determine their financial value as writers by being paid directly by their subscribers rather than through the publication for which they might have otherwise worked And now with Rushdie39s latest move one cannot help but wonder if we shall see a further influx of wellknown fiction writers and novelists as well as if those in the publishing industry might in turn begin launching similar barbs against Substack as those in the news media haveSubstack might reasonably be seen in the context of other platforms that have offered writers or users the ability to post their unvarnished commentaries sans an editorial process and with the opportunity to pursue individual monetization Platforms in this mold range from Medium to the upstart and admittedly now faltering alternative social media site Thinkspot And this of course also comes at a time when as I have covered in previous columns many of the legacy media brands are experiencing cratering credibility and public trustSubstack of course is not without criticism It has for instance been pilloried for an alleged lack of transparency about to which writers it has offered advances However in my view the more substantive criticism would be that Substack risks falling victim to the phenomenon that caused Huffington Post to disband its contributors platform in January of 2018 quotWhen everyone has a megaphone no one can be heardquot Just as concerns mount about the oversaturation of the podcast market quotYes I have a podcast Who doesn39tquot the same might be said of the everballooning number of writers established and aspiring alike who now have set up a Substack newsletterYet this has done little to assuage the growing anxiety on the part of many at the household name outlets about the risk that Substack and other similar upstart ventures might pose to their relative share of the conversation and the accompanying advertiser or subscriber dollars To this point Substack completed a 65 million round of new funding earlier this year has recently acquired the conversation platform Letter and enables some of its better known writers such as Andrew Sullivan to take home earnings in the sevenfigures far more than they would be paid at a given newspaper or magazine Time will of course tell if Substack follows the tech giants companies to which it is sometimes compared in beginning to moderate content a change of direction that would cause it likely to lose its competitive advantage In the meantime however the Substack quotmomentquot as today39s jargon would have it is more than just continuing Rushdie39s entrance shows that it is acceleratingClick the social buttons to share this content with your friends and colleaguesThe opinions and points of view expressed in this content are exclusively the views of the author andor subjects and do not necessarily represent the views of MediaVillagecomMyersBizNet Inc management or associated writers

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE MEDIAVILLAGE CONTENT | BECOME A THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CONTRIBUTOR

The Substack "Moment" Accelerates

Author

Publish date

Channel

Erich J. Prince

We Are the Outliers - By Jack Myers

More Videos:

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE MEDIAVILLAGE CONTENT | BECOME A THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CONTRIBUTOR

The Substack "Moment" Accelerates

Enjoying This Commentary? There's More to Love

Erich J. Prince

TAGS:

We Are the Outliers - By Jack Myers

Cookies