The Psychic and Social Effects of Media

Socrates and Plato the earliest philosophers known to most Westerners both highly esteemed quotthe soul39s conversation with itselfquot and leaned heavily toward the use of dialogic conversation as the secondbest media type because it mimicked the internal conversations which we have with ourselves Even in Plato39s use of writing he follows the form of spoken dialogues and he employs Socrates as his protagonistInvite job candidates to apply live during the Media and Advertising Communityamp8217s Black Talent Outreach Week at MediaVillagecom and AdvancingDiversityorg October 1720 Apply for jobssubmit your resume hereamp160Written language was just coming into vogue in their time and they warned against its use In Plato39s Phaedrus he has Socrates say as Socrates might have actually said to someone to the inventor of written languagequotThey will cease to exercise memory because they rely on that which is written calling things to remembrance no longer from within themselves but by means of external marksquotWhat you have discovered is a recipe not for memory but for reminder And it is no true wisdom that you offer your disciples but only the semblance of wisdom for by telling them of many things without teaching them you will make them seem to know much while for the most part they know nothing And as men filled not with wisdom but with the conceit of wisdom they will be a burden to their fellowsquotSocrates39 and Plato39s main concern was not that people in a writtenwordbased culture would suffer from memory atrophy so much as they would be injured by a lack of true indepth understanding such as could come through dialogue and further harmed by their mistaken belief that they had achieved understanding when they had notIn the 20th century media theorists such as Harold Innis Marshall McLuhan and Neil Postman thought and wrote deeply about the effects on culture history and the inner lives of human beings of the various media forms that in successive waves constrained and rerouted Earth civilization since that early beginning The spoken word and art were the first media revolutions followed by the written word the printing press photography cinema radio television the Internet and virtual realityIn the 1970s I wrote my own views in a treatise called Three Historic Shocks and the Modern Trance in which I painted tools weapons and media as the three turningpoint invention types with written language media being the most pivotal of these because it accelerated invention in general leading to massive information overload beyond our capability to assimilate as understanding beings the condition which exists today that I call AcceleritisNeil Postman had studied McLuhan who had studied Innis as Aristotle had studied Plato who had studied Socrates Of course I had been influenced by McLuhan but only recently have taken up reading Postman Interestingly Jack Myers had been an actual student of Postman39s and they collaborated on projects when Jack ran research at CBS which led to Jack39s selfidentification as a media ecologistAnother media ecologist at MediaVillage Stacey Lynn Schulman was another collaborator of Postman39s having traveled to Prague together right after the fall of communism thereOf the three in the lineage leading to Postman it is Postman who thoroughly ties up and illuminates the loose ends of the novel observations made by Innis and McLuhan in his mustread classic Amusing Ourselves to Death Public Discourse in the Age of Show BusinessPostman was concerned about the fate of humanity and saw the threat vectors through two alternative lenses those of Aldous Huxley Brave New World and George Orwell 1984 In Orwell39s view of the looming dangerous future the strong would take over the lives of the weak to a degree of totalitarian control that could never have been achieved without television and mass surveillance Big Brother Is Watching You In Huxley39s vision of dystopia it39s the opposite We Are Watching Big Brother it39s merely an amusing pastime and our lives consist of nothing but a series of trivial selfamusements Postman felt that the evidence as of 1985 pointed more strongly in the direction of Huxley39s world being the one that we are being sucked into like a black holeThe reason he pointed out was the nature of television itself Not only does television dictate the form of the content as every medium does it also conditions the substance conveyed Television by its nature focuses mostly on images and because the human mind seeks constant novelty new patterns never seen before and therefore quickly tires of sameness TV causes a need for speed to maintain the audience39s presence These forces result in most of the content on television including streaming and all devices moving quickly from one thing to another with emphasis on the attraction of the images more than the audio track Postman compellingly connects the dots to the superficial ultrashort attention span culture we have becomePostman39s issue was not with the superficiality of television but with the superficiality of all of us imposed by the entire culture being built around television Politics and religion becoming more like television Without the ability to follow a logical thread across many steps such as the Age of Print supported today the minds of too many of us autonomously flit from this to that A conspiracy theorist would claim that some bad people had conjured in advance to install ADDADHD across civilization Postman attributes these undesirable and perhaps disastrous mental habits to the endless discontinuities on television As he writes regarding one specific examplequotWe have become so accustomed to television news39 discontinuities that we are no longer struck dumb as any sane person would be by a newscaster who having just reported that a nuclear war is inevitable goes on to say that he will be right back after this word from Burger King who says in other words 39Now amp8230 this39 One can hardly overestimate the damage that such juxtapositions do to our sense of the world as a serious place The damage is especially massive to youthful viewers who depend so much on television for their clues as to how to respond to the worldquotIn our own words the mamp233lange of short bits of content mixing the ridiculous with the sublime in one congealed stream appears to train the subconscious that everything is equally unimportant What is lost by such a culture is a respect for the seriousness and divinity of lifeMcLuhan had explained that television sucks us into being part of a groupmind going on at that time leading to a suppression of individual identity and that loss of sense of identity is a principal cause of violenceThe hypnotic herd effect of television as seen from 1985 was yet to see the outcome of the development of interactivity These media thought leaders were well aware of the interactivity tests going on between 1976 and 2000 Some of them read my newsletter which had been guiding some of that development When interactivity came it had some of the good things I presaged and unfortunately some not so good things I had not expected The good thing is that it is a turn back toward individuality and identity brought by interactivity That was what drove me those years knowing that return to individualism at least would be one guaranteed outcome The interactive media give people back their sense of independent identity a form of selfexpression and of friendship In time we can steer it to be even better than it is right now Channel those creative energiesThe mass medium once called television but now revealed to be just one facet of screen media a broader framework that has already taken over jumped onto mobile phones mixed scribal culture with video culture and added more distractive forms of advertising into the bargainScreen media when I first got into the business captured four hours per day of the average US adult39s time but today that number has approximately tripled to include virtually every waking moment It strikes me that if Neil were still with us today he would be saying he told us so and explaining how the reentry of print through screens is not what he wanted that he wanted us to be able to read one thing deeply and with sustained continuity leading to true understanding which is a declining facultyNeil admits at the end of his magnum opus that education in the schools is the only hope and that he himself does not give it much hope of happening I agree with Neil Huxley and HG Wells that we are in a race between education and selfdestruction However I see that education happening not only through the schools but through all other media as well including the very media which are driving the problem The question is what sort of educationNeil alludes to teaching of critical thinking the ability to detach from the compulsions of the mindbending media stimuli To which I would add teaching metacognition the ability to study one39s own mind from the inside including the ability to focus on what had been subconscious and preconscious This ancient knowledge of the introspective method is what is sorely needed to bring us out of the two ditches Huxley and Orwell signposted and to empower individuals to manifest their positive creativityClick the social buttons to share this content with your friends and colleaguesThe opinions and points of view expressed in this content are exclusively the views of the author andor subjects and do not necessarily represent the views of MediaVillagecomMyersBizNet Inc management or associated writers

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE MEDIAVILLAGE CONTENT | BECOME A THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CONTRIBUTOR

The Psychic and Social Effects of Media

Author

Publish date

Channel

Archived in

Bill Harvey

FEMA and the Ad Council Encourage AANHPI Communities to Enhance Disaster Preparedness in New PSAs - Ad Council InSites

More Videos:

SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE MEDIAVILLAGE CONTENT | BECOME A THOUGHT LEADERSHIP CONTRIBUTOR

The Psychic and Social Effects of Media

Enjoying This Commentary? There's More to Love

Bill Harvey

TAGS:

FEMA and the Ad Council Encourage AANHPI Communities to Enhance Disaster Preparedness in New PSAs - Ad Council InSites

Cookies