As AI Turns Data into a Commodity, Human Creativity and Relationships will Become the Ultimate Competitive Edge
Data has been likened to oil, a comparison popularized by Michael Kassan years ago. Like oil, data fuels the engines of modern business. It lubricates decision-making processes, powers strategic models, and drives operational efficiency. Yet, as with oil, its extraction, refinement, and consumption have far-reaching consequences. As generative AI transforms the landscape, the acceleration of data availability and the sophistication of analytics are reaching unprecedented levels. The result is a paradox: as data becomes more abundant and accessible, its individual value is destined to decline. In this dynamic, the irreplaceable value of human relationships and creativity will become the true differentiator for leaders and organizations.
The Acceleration of Data and the Limits of Human Capacity
We are witnessing an era where data is not only being generated at exponential rates but also analyzed and implemented faster than human cognition can process. Generative AI systems have already outpaced human analytical capabilities, advancing to perform predictive analytics with increasing accuracy and reliability. These systems can detect patterns and project outcomes with a speed and scope that humans cannot replicate.
But this flood of information poses a critical challenge. The sheer volume and complexity of data have surpassed the human capacity to manage, analyze, and act upon it effectively. The integration of advanced machine learning is no longer a competitive advantage; it is a necessity. As AI systems automate and accelerate data processing, the focus is shifting from historical context to predictive accuracy, emphasizing the need for foresight over hindsight.
The Commoditization of Data and the Value Paradox
Yet, this acceleration leads to an inevitable commoditization of data. As AI systems become more ubiquitous, capable, and efficient, the competitive edge offered by access to information diminishes. When advanced predictive behavior modeling becomes standard, data ceases to be a differentiator. Instead, it becomes a common denominator -- an expected baseline, much like electricity or broadband.
Neil Postman once referred to much of modern information as "trash," noting that while it is abundant, it is often barely useful for informing the most basic tasks. In many ways, this reflects the trajectory of commoditized data. When every company can access sophisticated analytics, it is not the possession of data but the application of human insight, creativity, and relationship-building that will define success.
We see this commoditization already reshaping industries. Legacy media, for example, has been undermined by the efficiency of data-driven programmatic advertising and commerce media. The traditional value of curated editorial judgment and creative storytelling is threatened when cost-efficiency models dominate. But therein lies the opportunity: to rise above the data and assert the value of human creativity, differentiated ideas, and relationships.
The Environmental Impact of Data Extraction
The analogy to oil is particularly resonant when considering the broader implications of data extraction. The call to "drill, baby, drill" reflects an insatiable demand for more information. Yet, just as with oil, there are environmental consequences to this relentless pursuit.
For organizations, these consequences manifest in human terms. Over-reliance on data and AI-driven efficiencies risks dehumanizing the workplace. Job roles are shifting, some disappearing altogether, as AI systems take over analytical and predictive tasks. Organizational silos are breaking down, but so are traditional pathways for career growth and human connection. Emotional wellness, job satisfaction, and the intrinsic value of human contributions are under pressure in environments where data is seen as the ultimate authority.
Leaders must confront this reality. The human environment of an organization is as critical as its data systems. Investing in emotional wellness, fostering meaningful human connections, and ensuring job roles align with personal growth and creativity are essential for sustainable success. The challenge is not to halt the advance of AI, but to balance its integration with a reaffirmation of human value.
The Future of Information Providers in a Commoditized Data World
For information providers, the commoditization of data presents an existential question. If AI can analyze, predict, and automate with greater speed and accuracy, what remains for those whose business models depend on information dissemination? The answer lies in value-added differentiation.
In an era where data is ubiquitous, the power of ideas, creativity, and human relationships grows exponentially. Information providers must move beyond delivering data to offering insights that only human experience and intuition can provide. They must embrace creativity, storytelling, and differentiated thinking -- elements AI cannot replicate. Just as legacy media must lean into creative content that resonates beyond algorithms, information providers must champion ideas that elevate conversations and deepen understanding.
Witness the destructive force of data-driven efficiency on legacy media. Content that once thrived on originality and creative integrity now competes with commoditized clickbait and algorithm-driven narratives. The result has been a dilution of value and trust. But the antidote is not more data; it is more human insight. It is the courage to offer perspectives that challenge, engage, and inspire. The future of media -- and indeed all information-driven industries -- rests on the capacity to deliver uniquely human value.
The Human Imperative in the Age of AI
As outlined in my book The Tao of Leadership in the AI Era, the most valuable leadership tools will be those rooted in human-to-human communication and relationship-building. Trust, empathy, creativity, and strategic intuition cannot be commoditized. They are, and will remain, the exclusive domain of human interaction for at least another decade.
Organizations that prioritize these values will outpace those that rely solely on data-driven efficiency. In the near future, the differentiator will not be who possesses the best data, but who can forge the strongest relationships, develop the most creative ideas, and inspire the deepest trust. The art of leadership will be defined by the capacity to translate data insights into human-centric strategies that resonate authentically.
Redefining Value in the Data-Driven Future
The era of AI and accelerated data is not a threat to human value but a catalyst for redefining it. As data becomes more commoditized, human relationships, creativity, and emotional intelligence will emerge as the ultimate differentiators in business and leadership. The leaders who embrace this truth -- who balance technological advancement with human empathy -- will shape the future.
The message is clear: data may be the oil that powers the engines of commerce, but it is human creativity and connection that will drive organizations forward. In the end, it is not the volume of data that will define success, but the depth of relationships and the strength of ideas that leaders cultivate. That is the true imperative in the AI era.
Order Jack Myers best-selling book The Tao of Leadership: Harmonizing Technological Innovation and Human Creativity in the AI Era. Only$2.99 for the eBookin a limited offer from Amazon. Hard bound version is available at all booksellers.